Boo-tiful Icons

I like the approach with which you started working on the icon set. The thought process and the color scheme are well done👍.

But you should understand the difference between an icon and an illustration. An icon should have clean shapes, smooth and straight lines, minimum details to read well in the smallest size. Your icons won't work at a small size. Also, don't try to directly invert colors to go from a light theme to a dark theme. Try to be consistent in one theme, for example in a dark theme all icons should have the same stroke color, you have white stroke, black and orange - it's too much. And the set ends up looking uncohesive.

Anyway, thanks for your participation and try again in the future, I want to see your progress! 🙌

Really lovely illustrations! They might be a bit tricky to use as icons because of all the details. Simplifying them a little could help, but I really appreciate all the effort you put in. Great job, Zainab!

Good effort Zainab, however there is room for improvements.

Hi S! I love these illustrations! Unlike what some others have said, I can see these working great as icons for a video game or even a playful app! I really appreciate how you have made some rules that help define them as an icon set. Using the same angles for a lot of them. I would push you to consider color more. Some of the colors here just don't work as well as they could. I also would consider either taking away some details or adding in even more and really push for that game-like vibe. Keep up the good work! Happy Halloween!

As other reviewers already mentioned, just simplify your already cool illustrations. Try to take a step back and reverse-engineer it to a point where you have a good icon foundation. Try the Uxcel templates with the grids and layouts, they should help you!

Hello! Great job on the presentation and explaining your process, it was very clear.

I feel that it lacks context, like some mockup of the icon set in use. The icons also have too much detail and inconsistent styling.

It's a good start, but you cannot choose only one size of your icons... this means you have to redo the shape in order to get to a 20x20 and still be seen good